Should I Invest My House Down Payment in the Stock Market?

Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on email
Share on print

Let’s say you want to save up enough money for a down payment on a house. You’d like to invest your down payment and make it grow, so you can buy a home or condo in a couple of years, hopefully with some extra cash thanks to that investment. 

Sure, this seems like a good idea. But what you don’t know is how easy it is to lose money in the short term, instead of earning money, on the stock market – or how much you really stand to lose. Here, we’ll explain why investing in the stock market may not be a sure bet if you have a short-term time horizon of two years or less. 

What is Market Risk? Market Volatility In Short-Term Investing

To understand how stock market gains and losses work, we first need to look at market risk. Market risk is the underlying risk associated with investing that cannot be avoided or diversified away. That’s why diversification is so important – it can prevent your portfolio from completely tanking when faced with volatility. You have a financial goal that you plan to materialize in the near future? Market risk is your worst enemy.

So what are your odds of losing or winning on a short-term investment horizon of just two years? If we look at the last 90 years of the S&P 500, history shows that even with a diversified portfolio comprised of the 500 largest US public companies, you still have a roughly 24% chance of losing money over a two-year period. There can be huge dips and spikes from one year to the next. Odds are, you won’t just lose 2 or 3% of your money. Depending on whether it was a good year or not, you could lose even 30% or 40% of your initial investment.

This graph shows the rolling two-year returns of this index. 

*Bloomberg data.

Having a 75% chance of making money sounds pretty good. However, it doesn’t account for how much or how little you might win or lose. And if it’s a big loss, well – there goes your down payment. 

Not only that, but these averages also include extremely good periods, like the past 10 years, which are still considered among the best bull markets. If we look at the decade just before that (the 2000-2010s), the odds of losing money were much higher, at around 46% over 2 years. During the 2000s, if you invested in the stock market you basically flipped a coin and hoped you wouldn’t lose money over a two-year period. 

If you had invested your home down payment at some point in the 2000s, hoping to grow it and take it out in a couple of years, you could have easily lost up to half of your cash – depending on how unlucky you were. That’s why a long-term approach to investing is so important. 

*Bloomberg data

5-Year, 10-Year, and 15-Year Period Investments

We know investing in the stock market for just two years in the hope of winning some money is a risky bet. But what about five years, 10 years or 15 years? What are the odds then? 

At five years, the odds of losing on your initial investment are slightly better, at approximately 21%. So if you’re looking to make money on your down payment on a house in five years, that’s a better time horizon to consider, but it’s not for the risk-averse. After all, there’s still a 1 in 5 chance that you’ll end up with less money than you put in.

Another thing to keep in mind is the current Canadian housing market, which shows no signs of slowing down. Even if you experience some modest gains on your down payment in the stock market, you might still be priced out of the market in five years – depending on the city you live in. The odds of experiencing a lucky windfall that will cover for the rising cost of homes becomes even smaller. 

What about 10 years? With a longer time horizon, your chances improve substantially. Your odds of losing money over a 10-year period fall to 12% and less than 4% at 15 years. Remember, how much you lose or gain depends on your initial investment and other factors. But you’re still far less likely to lose half of your investment or more when you are invested over a longer period of time. 

These probabilities are based on the S&P 500 Index alone, without the dividends. While similar over two years, the odds of losing money over five, 10 or 15 years become much lower when considering the dividends that would be included in the S&P 500 Total Return Index.

Of course, growing your house downpayment slowly over 15 years isn’t realistic for most people. But long-term investing is a surefire way to grow your wealth for retirement, a child’s or grandchild’s education and other, longer-term goals. 

Short-Term Stock Trading: Proceed With Caution 

It’s never been easier or more affordable to access the stock market. Thanks to robo-advisors and apps like WealthSimple or Robinhood, the barriers to entering the stock market have never been lower. Over the last few years, the trend towards short-term trading – with big risks and potentially huge wins and losses – makes investing look more like gambling. It may be very tempting to take your hard-earned savings and try to grow them in the short term by trading stocks. But short-term investing can have negative, long-lasting implications on your portfolio, and real implications on your life goals if you aren’t careful. 

Entering the market at the right time can have a significant influence on your success, especially if you’re only investing for two years. But timing the market perfectly is nearly impossible. The best strategy for most of us is not to try to market-time at all, but instead, make a plan and start investing regularly as soon as possible. 

If you still want to try your hand at short-term investing, you should only put a small portion of your available assets in the market – a portion small enough that it won’t prevent you from buying the house of your dreams when you finally find it.

Post Author

Author

  • Alexandre graduated from HEC Montréal in 2016. During the second year of his baccalaureate, he was given an internship at one of Canada’s largest wealth management firms. He remained in this role until he began his career in 2017 as a branch administrator for that same firm. He also served on a board of directors for the largest financial cooperative in Quebec. Alexandre joined Claret’s team in the summer of 2018, first as a trader and analyst, and transitioned into the role of Relationship Manager the following year. On a personal note, during his studies, Alexandre earned the Governor General of Canada’s Academic Bronze Medal.

Your wealth matters.

Sign up to our Newsletter for updates on when we publish new insights.